Last Updated on April 14, 2026
The Murdoch Mysteries novels, penned by Canadian author Maureen Jennings, have captivated readers and television audiences alike with their compelling blend of historical fiction and detective intrigue.
Set in late 19th-century Toronto, these novels follow the adventures of Detective William Murdoch, a forward-thinking investigator who employs innovative forensic techniques to solve complex crimes.
Jennings’ meticulous research and vivid storytelling bring Victorian-era Toronto to life, offering readers a glimpse into a world of gas-lit streets, horse-drawn carriages, and societal upheaval.
The books have not only garnered critical acclaim but also inspired the long-running television series Murdoch Mysteries, which has become a cultural phenomenon in Canada and beyond.
So, let’s take a better look into the books that inspired the show…
Murdoch Mystery Books in Order
Except the Dying (1997)
In this series debut, Detective William Murdoch investigates the murder of a young, pregnant servant girl found frozen in a snowy lane.
As he delves into the case, Murdoch uncovers secrets that those closest to the victim are desperate to hide.
Under the Dragon’s Tail (1998)
Murdoch faces a complex case involving the murder of Dolly Merishaw, a midwife and abortionist known for her discretion and contempt for her clients.
The discovery of a dead boy in Dolly’s kitchen complicates the investigation, suggesting the presence of multiple killers.
Poor Tom Is Cold (2001)
When a constable is found dead, apparently by suicide, Murdoch suspects foul play.
His investigation leads him to uncover a plot involving the constable’s evil stepchildren.
Let Loose the Dogs (2003)
Murdoch’s personal and professional lives collide when he reopens a decade-old murder case in which his father was the prime suspect.
As he seeks the truth, Murdoch must confront his own troubled past.
Night’s Child (2005)
The detective investigates a case involving child pornography after 13-year-old Agnes Fisher faints at school.
The investigation leads Murdoch into the dark underbelly of Toronto’s society.
Vices of My Blood (2006)
Murdoch tackles the murder of an Anglican priest, uncovering a web of secrets and lies within the church community.
A Journeyman to Grief (2007)
Set against the backdrop of Toronto’s small but growing Black community, Murdoch investigates the abduction of a young Black woman, revealing tensions and prejudices of the era.
Let Darkness Bury the Dead (2017)
Set in 1917, this novel takes place 20 years after the previous books.
An older Murdoch, now a senior detective, must solve a murder case while dealing with his son’s return from the Great War.
How Do The Books Differ From The TV Show?
However closely a tv show tries to match an original novel, there are always going to be differences.
Case in point is Murdoch Mysteries where only eight books were written, yet the show has 312 episodes over 18 seasons.
There has to be some dramatic licences and so there are several key ways in which they differ.
The most significant difference lies in the overall tone of the stories. The television series adopts a much lighter and more comedic approach compared to the novels.
While the books by Maureen Jennings are described as dark and somber, the TV show presents a more jovial and lighthearted atmosphere.
Although the core characters remain the same, their portrayals in the TV series differ somewhat from their book counterparts:
In the books, Murdoch is described as more brooding and complex. The TV version, played by Yannick Bisson, has a more polished and conventionally attractive appearance.
The TV series also expands on the roles of characters like Dr. Julia Ogden, Inspector Brackenreid, and Constable George Crabtree, giving them more prominent storylines and developed personalities.
There are also more creative liberties with historical accuracy and scientific innovations.
For example, the show often features Murdoch creating prototype versions of modern technologies, adding a steampunk-like element to the series.
And, while the books incorporate historical context, the TV show frequently includes cameo appearances by famous historical figures, sometimes in fanciful scenarios.
While both the books and the TV series are set in late 19th-century Toronto, the show expands its scope over time, incorporating broader historical events and social issues of the era.
Despite these differences, the TV adaptation has been well-received by Maureen Jennings herself. She appreciates the show’s attention to historical detail and sees it as excellent publicity for her books.
The success of the television series has brought renewed interest to the original novels, allowing both formats to coexist and appeal to different audience preferences.
How Successful are the Novels?
The Murdoch Mysteries novels, and the adapted tv show, have become a cultural phenomenon in Canada and gained international acclaim.
The show premiered on Citytv in 2008 and later moved to CBC, where it found an even larger audience.
The series has garnered numerous accolades, including nominations for multiple Gemini Awards and Canadian Screen Awards. In 2016, 2017, and 2018, it was the highest-rated scripted television series in Canada, winning the Golden Screen Award in 2017, 2018, and 2020.
The show’s success extends beyond Canada, with millions of viewers in more than 100 countries tuning in to follow Detective Murdoch’s investigations. Its popularity has led to fan conventions, merchandise, and themed events, further solidifying its place in popular culture.
The television adaptation has also sparked renewed interest in the original novels. Many viewers have been inspired to explore Jennings’ books, appreciating the deeper characterization and historical detail they offer.
While the TV series takes some liberties with the source material, it remains true to the spirit of Jennings’ creation, capturing the atmosphere of Victorian-era Toronto and showcasing Murdoch’s innovative detective methods.
Maureen Jennings
Maureen Jennings was born on April 23, 1939, in Birmingham, England. Her early years were marked by the loss of her father during World War II, an experience that would later influence her writing.
At the age of 17, Jennings emigrated to Canada with her mother, settling first in Windsor, Ontario, before moving to Toronto in 1960.
Jennings’ academic journey led her to earn a BA in Psychology and Philosophy from Assumption University (now the University of Windsor) and later an MA in English Literature from the University of Toronto.
Her career path was diverse, including stints as a high school teacher and a faculty member at Ryerson Polytechnic Institute (now Toronto Metropolitan University).
Before embarking on her writing career, Jennings worked as a psychotherapist for many years, an experience that undoubtedly contributed to her keen understanding of human nature and motivation.
Her transition to full-time writing was gradual, as she slowly reduced her therapy practice to focus on her literary ambitions.
Jennings’ fascination with social history, particularly Toronto’s Victorian roots, inspired her to create the Detective Murdoch series.
Her debut novel, Except the Dying, was published in 1997 and marked the beginning of a successful writing career that has spanned over two decades.
Conclusion
Maureen Jennings’ Murdoch Mysteries novels have left an indelible mark on the landscape of Canadian literature and television.
Through her meticulous research and engaging storytelling, Jennings has brought the world of Victorian Toronto to life, creating a character in William Murdoch who resonates with readers and viewers alike.
The success of the book series and its television adaptation demonstrates the enduring appeal of historical mysteries and the public’s fascination with innovative detective work.
As the television series continues to gain new fans around the world, it also serves as a gateway for many to discover Jennings’ original novels.
These books offer a richer, more nuanced exploration of the characters and their world, providing us with a deeper understanding of the social and historical context in which the stories are set.
The Murdoch Mystery series stands as a testament to Jennings’ skill as a writer and her ability to blend historical fact with compelling fiction.
Whether experienced through the pages of a book or on the small screen, this Canadian detective will remain a beloved figure in the realm of mystery fiction for years to come.
